fencing and trees planted by the river

Right tree, right place

By Michael Rogers, Head of Conservation

We all know the multiple benefits trees bring to our landscape. They provide us with oxygen, shade, rainfall interception, ground stability and protection from erosion. They provide habitat for an enormous assortment of wildlife, from birds, bats and small mammals to an incredible array of invertebrates including moths and butterflies.

Trees have a major role to play in tackling our climate and biodiversity crisis along with other carbon-storing habitats like peatland, fen, bog and floodplain grassland.

In Cumbria, managing and reducing flood risk remains a key focus – and trees do help reduce flood risk. Rain hits the ground at higher speeds where there is a lack of tree cover, whilst a canopy of leaves, branches and trunks slows down the rain before it hits the ground simply by getting in the way (interception) and slowing its route to the ground and running off into the river. Some of the water will evaporate back into the atmosphere directly from the canopy without ever reaching the ground.

Root systems also help water penetrate deeper into the soil at a faster rate under and around trees. This means less surface run-off and more water storage in the soil and that can help slow the flow of water which in turn take the peak off the flood downstream.

Woodland cover in the UK is one of the lowest in Europe. One third of all woodland wildlife species are in decline and one in 10 woodland wildlife species are at risk of extinction (Woodland Trust, 2021). We know we need more trees and planting a young sapling or a whip is one of the most compelling and satisfying things we can do in the world of conservation land management. But we cannot just plant trees.

It needs to be the right tree, in the right place.

Right place – this is key to ensuring time isn’t wasted on planting trees that won’t survive and flourish, and absolutely critically, won’t damage other equally important habitats such as rare grassland – such as upland hay meadows and floodplain meadows, and carbon-storing ecosystems such as peatland. Like woodlands peat bogs hold carbon, but not through trees. Peat is formed by dead vegetation that is unable to fully decompose in the waterlogged environment. Because the plants’ decomposition is incomplete, their carbon is not released into the atmosphere; it is instead locked up in peat.

Globally, the carbon stored in peat is estimated to be twice that found in forests and whilst both are important, the absence of tree cover from the bog system ensures peat forming sphagnum mosses can thrive.

The right species of tree in the right place reduces the chance that pests, diseases, natural disasters and other threats can make a drastic impact on a habitat or area. For example, take the current loss we face from the threat of ash dieback disease: we are set to lose around 80% of ash trees in the UK, and this will have a devastating impact on the landscape and the species that rely on the tree. To mitigate some of the damage, we need to plant (or encourage natural regeneration) of other species of trees not impacted by the disease to replace the role of ash in the ecosystem.

The type of tree planted can also benefit in other ways:

To boost wildlife, native British trees with nuts and berries such as rowan and hazel can provide food throughout the year.

As a shelter for livestock, native species like oak, wild cherry and downy birch are a good source of shade in summer as well as shelter from the elements over winter.

To prevent soil erosion and reduce flooding, trees that are suitable for riparian planting or in a damp field corner, include alder and willow (however if considering planting near a main river, talk to the Environment Agency to ensure it is allowed in your area).

And you don’t even have to have a lot of space. Yes, there are grants and incentives out there to plant woodlands, but it is also important to plant hedgerows, wood pasture, scrub and give woodland edges more structure. It all helps!


So why is it so important to plant the right tree, in the right place? Well as we have experienced in the Croglin Valley not taking care of tree planting before and after can result in massive losses.

Over the last 10 years, landowners in the Croglin Valley entered into various woodland planting schemes. It is hard to estimate the total amount of trees planted, but there have been at least 80,000, possibly much more, and the survival rate has been hampered by several elements.

The Woodland Trust carried out a full walkover report on the condition of the tree planting in the valley in 2018/2019. Eden Rivers Trust, through our Slow the Flow funding (Environment Agency) is addressing the priority items that were identified in this report.

These were:

  • Trees struggling to grow on the fellside due to high winds pushing trees over (see left),
  • Deer pushing trees over and nibbling tops off trees planted in shorter tubes,
  • Sheep getting into fenced areas and eating trees,
  • Voles getting into the bottom of the tubes- nesting there and eating the bark from around the roots and lower stem of the tree,
  • Trees becoming top heavy and falling over, or
  • Stakes starting to rot after five years.

If you have recently planted trees, some of the issues found on the fellside in Croglin may be familiar, so here are our tips on how to address them:

  • Simple, regular maintenance will manage most issues.
    • Regular checking of trees, tubes and stakes will identify where stakes need to be replaced, trees need picking back up or where trees have died. You can then decide whether it is viable to replace the sapling or not.
      Trees take longer to grow on the fellside so may outlive the life of the stake and it may need to be replaced.
    • Use a short tube from a dead tree on top of the existing tube to deter animals as the tree grows (see picture right).
    • Ensure the base of the tube is pushed into the ground to stop animals from climbing underneath.


If you’re interested in finding out more about how trees and/or other natural flood management measures could help your farmland to become more flood resilient and improve the ecosystem, please get in touch with us on 01768 866788 or email office@edenrt.org


Eden Rivers Kingfisher Icon
Eden Rivers Kingfisher Icon